Data Breach
A data breach is the unauthorized access, disclosure, or loss of sensitive personal or organizational data, from Social Security numbers and medical records to trade secrets and login credentials. Every data breach compromises the confidentiality, integrity, or security of the information involved, and the worst incidents compromise all three. Verizon’s 2026 investigations report counted more than 22,000 confirmed breaches across 145 countries, nearly double the prior year’s count. For businesses holding Californians’ information, a breach also starts legal duties under the oldest notification law in the country. The state passed the first breach notification statute in 2002.
What is a Data Breach?
A data breach is an incident in which protected data is accessed, copied, or exposed by someone who has no authorization to see it. A data breach can come from an outside hacker, an employee’s mistake, or an insider who misuses access they were legitimately given. What separates a breach from an ordinary security incident is the data. A blocked phishing email or a failed login attempt is a security incident, but it becomes a breach only when protected information actually leaves the owner’s control. Verizon draws the same line in its research, and its 2026 report separated about 31,000 security incidents from roughly 22,000 confirmed breaches.
How is a Data Breach Defined Under Data Protection Laws?
California Civil Code section 1798.82 defines a breach of the security of the system as the unauthorized acquisition of computerized data that compromises the security, confidentiality, or integrity of personal information a business maintains. The statutory definition of a data breach centers on acquisition. A business must notify state residents whose unencrypted personal information was acquired, or is reasonably believed to have been acquired, by an unauthorized person. Encrypted data triggers notice only if the encryption key or security credential was also taken. Other laws use different wording. The federal HIPAA Breach Notification Rule treats a breach as an impermissible use or disclosure of protected health information that compromises its security or privacy. The California Consumer Privacy Act ties its lawsuit right to unauthorized access and exfiltration, theft, or disclosure caused by a business’s failure to keep reasonable security.
What Qualifies as a Personal Data Breach?
A personal data breach qualifies under California law when a person’s name is exposed together with at least one sensitive data element, and the information was not encrypted. The personal data breach rule covers a full first name or a first initial, plus the last name. Civil Code section 1798.82(h) lists the data elements that make the exposure reportable.
- Government identifiers such as a Social Security number, driver’s license or California ID number, tax identification number, passport number, or military ID number
- Financial account numbers, including credit and debit card numbers, when combined with any code or password that allows access to the account
- Medical information and health insurance information
- Biometric data collected from physical characteristics, such as a fingerprint or retina image used to verify identity
- Genetic data and information collected through an automated license plate recognition system
Login credentials qualify without a name attached. Under section 1798.82(h)(2), a username or email address combined with a password or security answer that opens an online account is personal information. For a credentials-only breach, the business can satisfy notice by telling the person to change the password and security question.
What is the Difference Between a Data Breach and a Data Leak?
A data breach usually means someone gained unauthorized access to information, while a data leak means information was exposed by accident or without control, often with no attacker involved. A cloud storage folder set to public access is the classic data leak example, because no one had to break in to reach the files. Leaks often come from a misconfigured database or a spreadsheet sent to the wrong person. California’s statute never uses the word leak, so the legal question is the same for both. A leak becomes a reportable breach once an unauthorized person acquires the exposed personal information, or once the business reasonably believes someone did. A company that finds a leak checks its access logs for downloads before deciding on notice.
When does Unauthorized Access Become a Data Breach?
Unauthorized access becomes a data breach under California law when the person who gets in acquires unencrypted personal information, or when the business reasonably believes they did. Unauthorized access to a system that holds no personal information, or to data that stayed encrypted with the key secure, does not by itself trigger notice under section 1798.82. The statute also carves out good faith acquisition by an employee or agent acting for the business, as long as the information is not used or disclosed further. An employee who opens a customer file while doing their job has not caused a breach. If that employee copies the file and sells it, the exception no longer applies.
What are the Causes of Data Breaches?
Data breaches are caused by outside attacks, human error, insider misuse, and weaknesses at outside vendors, and most incidents involve more than one of these at the same time. Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report found a human element in 62% of breaches, even as software flaws became the leading way attackers got in.
- Vulnerability exploitation is an attack on an unpatched flaw in software or network equipment, and it was the initial entry point in 31% of breaches in Verizon’s 2026 report, overtaking stolen credentials for the first time in the report’s 19-year history.
- Stolen credentials are passwords taken through phishing, malware that records logins, or earlier breaches, then reused to log in as a real employee.
- Phishing and social engineering trick a person into revealing a password, approving a login, or opening a malicious file, and attackers increasingly use text messages and phone calls instead of email.
- Ransomware locks or steals an organization’s data and demands payment, and it appeared in 48% of the breaches Verizon analyzed in 2026.
- Human error covers misdirected emails, misconfigured cloud storage, and documents published without redaction.
- Third-party compromise happens when a vendor, software supplier, or service provider with access to the data is breached, and Verizon’s 2025 report found third-party involvement in 30% of breaches, double the prior year.
- Lost or stolen devices expose data stored on laptops, phones, and drives without encryption. In October 2011 a computer stolen from a Sutter Health office held records for more than 4 million patients.
How do Hackers Typically Cause Data Breaches in Companies?
Hackers usually get into a company by exploiting an unpatched software flaw or by logging in with stolen credentials, then move through the network until they find data worth copying. Hackers in Verizon’s 2026 data most often entered through vulnerability exploitation, which accounted for 31% of initial access. Security researchers commenting on the report noted that AI tools have cut the time between a flaw’s disclosure and its exploitation from months to hours. Edge devices such as VPN gateways and firewalls are common targets because they face the internet and are often patched late. Once inside, an attacker raises their account privileges, finds file servers and databases, and copies the data out before anyone notices. Stolen passwords feed this cycle. Verizon’s 2025 report found that 54% of ransomware victims had company domains appear in logs from password-stealing malware before the attack. In California, this conduct is also a crime under Penal Code section 502, the Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act.
What is a Ransomware-Related Data Breach?
A ransomware-related data breach is a cyberattack in which criminals encrypt an organization’s files and demand payment to restore access, often after first stealing a copy of the data. A ransomware attack that includes theft is called double extortion, because the attackers threaten to publish the stolen records if the victim refuses to pay. Ransomware appeared in 48% of breaches in Verizon’s 2026 report, up from 44% a year earlier. The same report put the median ransom payment at $139,875 and found that 69% of victims did not pay. Paying does not end the legal obligations. If personal information was acquired during the attack, California’s 30-day notice deadline applies whether or not the business paid. Federal health regulators presume that ransomware encryption of protected health information is a reportable breach unless the organization shows a low probability that the data was compromised.
Can Insider Threats Lead to Data Breaches?
Yes, insider threats cause data breaches when an employee, contractor, or business partner misuses access they were legitimately given. Insider threats include deliberate acts, such as an employee selling customer records to an identity thief. They also include careless ones, such as a staff member browsing files they have no job reason to open. California’s good faith exception protects only access for the business’s own purposes. When an insider uses or discloses the data beyond that purpose, the access becomes a breach that may require notice. Hospitals see this often, and the California Department of Public Health has penalized licensed facilities after employees viewed patient records without a treatment or work reason.
What are Accidental Data Breaches in Organizations?
Accidental data breaches happen when human error or a configuration mistake exposes personal information without any attacker involved. Accidental data breaches are common because they need only one wrong click or one unchecked setting. Typical examples include the following.
- Sending an email or attachment with personal data to the wrong recipient, often because of address autocomplete
- Mailing benefit statements or medical bills to the wrong household
- Leaving a cloud storage folder or database open to the public internet
- Publishing a document online without removing Social Security numbers or account numbers
- Losing an unencrypted laptop, phone, or USB drive
An accident does not excuse notice. If the misdirected file contained unencrypted personal information and the recipient was not authorized to receive it, the business has the same reporting duties it would have after a hack. Encryption is the main protection, since California’s notice duty generally does not apply to data that stayed encrypted with the key secure.
What Laws Apply to Data Breaches?
Data breaches involving Californians are governed by state notification and security statutes plus federal laws that depend on the industry and the type of data. Data breach laws impose two kinds of duties. One set requires organizations to protect data before a breach, and the other requires them to report and respond after one.
- California Customer Records Act, Civil Code sections 1798.80 to 1798.84, requires businesses to keep reasonable security (section 1798.81.5), sets breach notice rules (section 1798.82), and lets injured customers sue (section 1798.84).
- Civil Code section 1798.29 applies the same notice duties to California state agencies.
- California Consumer Privacy Act, as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act (Proposition 24), gives consumers a right to sue over breaches caused by unreasonable security under section 1798.150 and is enforced by the California Privacy Protection Agency and the Attorney General.
- Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, Civil Code section 56 and following, protects medical information held by health care providers and allows $1,000 nominal damages for negligent release.
- Health and Safety Code section 1280.15 requires licensed clinics, hospitals, home health agencies, and hospices to report medical information breaches to the California Department of Public Health.
- HIPAA Breach Notification Rule covers health plans, health care providers, and their business associates nationwide.
- Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act Safeguards Rule requires non-bank financial institutions, including auto dealers that offer financing, to report certain breaches to the Federal Trade Commission.
- SEC cybersecurity disclosure rules require public companies to disclose material cybersecurity incidents to investors.
What are the Legal Obligations After a Data Breach Occurs?
After a data breach, an organization must contain it, investigate what was taken, and notify the people and agencies the law requires. In California, notice of a data breach is due to affected residents within 30 calendar days of discovery. Senate Bill 446 set that deadline effective January 1, 2026, replacing the earlier standard of notice in the most expedient time possible and without unreasonable delay. The steps usually run in this order.
- Contain the breach by closing the entry point, resetting compromised accounts, and isolating affected systems.
- Preserve evidence such as logs, images of affected machines, and attacker communications, because regulators and courts may later ask for them.
- Investigate the scope, often with an outside forensic firm, to learn which records were acquired and whose they were.
- Notify affected California residents within 30 calendar days, unless law enforcement requests a delay or more time is needed to determine the scope and restore the system.
- Offer identity theft protection at no cost for at least 12 months when the business was the source of the breach and Social Security, driver’s license, or California ID numbers were exposed.
- Submit a sample notice to the Attorney General within 15 calendar days of notifying residents when more than 500 Californians are affected.
- Report to sector regulators, such as HHS, the FTC, or the SEC, when federal law applies.
The individual notice must be written in plain language and titled “Notice of Data Breach.” It must be organized under five headings, What Happened?, What Information Was Involved?, What We Are Doing, What You Can Do, and For More Information. A company that maintains data it does not own, such as a payroll processor, must notify the data owner, who then has 30 days to notify the affected people.
When Must a Company Report a Data Breach to Authorities?
A company must report a data breach by the deadline set by each law that covers it. For most California data breach reports, the clock starts on the day the breach is discovered. The deadlines differ by industry and by the number of people affected, so a single breach at a hospital or lender can create three or four separate reporting duties.
| Law | Who it covers | Who must be told | Deadline |
| Civil Code 1798.82 | Businesses with Californians’ personal information | Affected California residents | 30 calendar days from discovery or notification |
| Civil Code 1798.82(f) | Breaches affecting more than 500 Californians | California Attorney General | 15 calendar days after notifying residents |
| Health and Safety Code 1280.15 | Licensed clinics, health facilities, home health agencies, hospices | Patient and California Department of Public Health | 15 business days after detection |
| HIPAA Breach Notification Rule | Health plans, providers, business associates | Individuals, HHS, and media when more than 500 residents of a state are affected | 60 calendar days from discovery |
| GLBA Safeguards Rule | Non-bank financial institutions | Federal Trade Commission, for 500 or more consumers | 30 days from discovery |
| SEC Form 8-K, Item 1.05 | Public companies | Investors | 4 business days after the incident is found material |
Law enforcement can pause some of these clocks. California allows a delay when a law enforcement agency determines that notice would impede a criminal investigation. The FTC rule allows an initial 30-day delay, extendable by 60 days on a written request.
What Penalties Apply for Failing to Report a Data Breach?
Failing to report a data breach on time can lead to customer lawsuits, regulatory fines, and court orders, and the penalties grow with the number of people affected. Penalties for a late or missing data breach notice start with Civil Code section 1798.84, which lets any injured customer sue for damages. A court can also order the business to comply. Licensed health facilities face the most specific penalty schedule. The California Department of Public Health may assess $100 for each day a breach goes unreported to the department or the patient, up to $250,000 per reported event. That is in addition to penalties of up to $25,000 per patient whose information was accessed without authorization. Under the 2025 inflation adjustment, the California Privacy Protection Agency can impose fines of up to $2,663 per violation. Intentional violations and those involving minors under 16 carry up to $7,988 each. Federal regulators add their own exposure through HHS civil money penalties for HIPAA violations and FTC enforcement against financial institutions. Late notice also hurts a company in court, because victims who learned of a breach months late can argue they lost the chance to freeze credit or watch their accounts.
How do Courts Determine Damages in Data Breach Lawsuits?
Courts determine damages in data breach lawsuits by measuring what each plaintiff lost, such as fraudulent charges, identity theft costs, and time spent repairing credit. Damages in a data breach lawsuit can also come from a fixed amount set by statute. California’s privacy statutes give injured consumers that second path through statutory damages, which can be awarded without proof of a specific dollar loss. Under the California Consumer Privacy Act, a consumer whose unencrypted data was exposed because of unreasonable security can recover $107 to $799 per incident. Those are the inflation-adjusted amounts for 2025 and 2026, and the consumer can recover actual damages instead if they are greater. Before seeking those statutory damages, the consumer must give the business 30 days’ written notice and a chance to cure. Class size drives the totals. A breach affecting 10,000 Californians carries statutory exposure between $1,070,000 and $7,990,000 before any actual damages or attorney’s fees.
Actual damages require evidence. Plaintiffs typically document unauthorized transactions, the cost of credit monitoring and freezes, lost wages from time spent on recovery, and emotional distress where the law allows it. Courts rely on forensic reports showing what data left the network and dark web monitoring that shows the data was offered for sale. Economists and other retained witnesses then testify to the value of the loss. Medical records claims carry an extra requirement. California courts in Regents of the University of California v. Superior Court (2013) and Sutter Health v. Superior Court (2014) held that a patient seeking $1,000 nominal damages under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act must show an unauthorized person viewed the records. In federal court, the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2021 decision in TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez requires each class member to show a concrete harm to have standing to sue for damages.
Which Authorities Must be Informed After a Data Breach?
The authorities that must be informed after a data breach depend on the type of data, the organization’s industry, and how many people were affected. Affected individuals come first under every data breach law, and a California business may need to notify these parties.
- Affected individuals must be notified under Civil Code section 1798.82 whenever their unencrypted personal information was acquired.
- The California Attorney General must receive a sample notice when more than 500 California residents are affected by one breach.
- The California Department of Public Health must be told of medical information breaches at licensed health facilities.
- The HHS Office for Civil Rights receives HIPAA breach reports, immediately for 500 or more people and in an annual log for smaller breaches.
- The Federal Trade Commission receives reports from non-bank financial institutions when 500 or more consumers are affected.
- The Securities and Exchange Commission receives Form 8-K disclosures from public companies after a material incident.
- Prominent media outlets must be notified under HIPAA when more than 500 residents of one state are affected.
- Other states’ regulators may need notice when residents of those states are affected, because each state applies its own breach law.
Reporting to law enforcement, such as the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center, is generally voluntary under California’s statute, although it can justify a delay in individual notice. Requirements vary by law and change often, so the list a company must notify depends on the facts of each breach.
Can a Personal Injury Attorney Handle Data Breach Cases?
Some personal injury attorneys handle data breach cases, particularly when a breach leads to identity theft, financial loss, or emotional distress for an individual client. A personal injury attorney already works with the core of most data breach claims. That core is proving a company owed a duty of care, failed to meet it, and caused measurable harm. The fit is strongest when the breach harmed a specific person in a specific way, such as fraud that ruined a client’s credit or a medical records exposure that caused real distress. Large breaches are different. Those cases are usually filed as class actions under the California Consumer Privacy Act and the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act. They often involve attorneys focused on privacy litigation, working with forensic investigators and cybersecurity consultants who reconstruct how the attack happened. Many consumers can also join an existing class settlement without hiring their own lawyer.
Who is Legally Responsible for a Data Breach in a Company?
The company that owns or licenses the data is usually legally responsible for a data breach, although vendors that store or process the data for it can share that liability. Legal responsibility for a data breach starts with Civil Code section 1798.81.5. That statute requires businesses that own, license, or maintain Californians’ personal information to use security procedures suited to the nature of the information. The duty extends to vendors through contract, because a business that shares personal information with an outside company must require it to protect the data too.
Vendor breaches are common. Verizon’s 2025 report found third-party involvement in 30% of breaches. When a vendor is breached, state law requires the vendor to notify the data owner, which then notifies the affected people. The hacker is criminally liable under Penal Code section 502. Most attackers are never identified or are outside the United States, though, so civil claims usually target the company and its vendors. The Attorney General’s 2016 Data Breach Report named the Center for Internet Security’s Critical Security Controls as a minimum level of reasonable security, and plaintiffs often measure a company’s practices against that list.
How is Negligence Proven in a Data Breach Case?
Negligence in a data breach case is proven by showing that the company did not use reasonable security measures and that this failure caused the plaintiff’s harm. The concept of negligence in law asks whether the company acted as a reasonably careful business would have in the same position, not whether it stopped every attack. A plaintiff usually has to establish four points.
- The company owed a duty to protect the data, which California courts and section 1798.81.5 recognize for businesses that collect personal information.
- The company fell short of that duty, such as by leaving a known vulnerability unpatched for months, storing Social Security numbers unencrypted, or skipping multi-factor authentication on remote access.
- That shortfall caused the breach, which is often shown through the forensic investigation report.
- The plaintiff suffered harm that can be measured, such as fraud losses, credit monitoring costs, or time lost to recovery.
The strongest evidence usually comes from the company’s own records. Prior security audits that flagged the problem, ignored employee warnings, and vendor alerts about the exploited flaw can show the company knew of the risk. Some California courts have dismissed negligence claims seeking only economic losses under the economic loss rule. For that reason, plaintiffs often pair negligence with statutory claims that do not carry that limit.
Can Companies be Sued for Failing to Prevent Data Breaches?
Yes, companies can be sued for failing to prevent data breaches when the breach resulted from unreasonable security and caused harm. Companies sued in California typically face claims under section 1798.150 of the California Consumer Privacy Act and section 1798.84 of the Customer Records Act. Medical data adds the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, and most complaints include the Unfair Competition Law, negligence, and breach of contract. These suits are usually class actions. The outcome depends on the evidence of the company’s security practices and on proof of harm. A large share of these cases end in settlements that fund credit monitoring and cash payments.
What is the Difference Between Negligence and Cyber Liability in Breaches?
Negligence is a legal claim that a company failed to take reasonable care with data. Cyber liability is broader, meaning the full legal and financial responsibility a company carries for data security risks whether or not it was careless. The term cyber liability covers notification costs, regulatory fines, contract claims from business partners, forensic investigation, and lawsuits, and insurers sell policies built around those losses. A company can face that exposure with no negligence at all. California requires notice to affected residents even when the company’s security was reasonable and the attacker was unusually skilled.
| Point of comparison | Negligence | Cyber liability |
| What it is | A claim that the company lacked reasonable care | Total legal and financial exposure from a data security incident |
| Source | Common law and California case law | Statutes, regulations, contracts, and common law |
| Fault required | Yes, the plaintiff must prove unreasonable conduct | Not always, since notice duties apply regardless of fault |
| Who pursues it | Individual plaintiffs or a class | Consumers, regulators, and business partners |
| Typical result | Damages for proven harm | Notice costs, fines, settlements, and remediation spending |
Is Strict Liability Applicable in Data Breach Cases?
No, California does not generally apply strict liability in data breach cases, so plaintiffs must show the company’s security fell short or that it released data negligently. A rule of strict liability makes a defendant pay for harm regardless of how careful it was, and the state reserves it for areas such as defective products and abnormally dangerous activities. Privacy statutes are written around fault instead. The Consumer Privacy Act allows a lawsuit only when a breach resulted from the business’s failure to keep reasonable security. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act provides damages for negligent release of medical information. Plaintiffs in Sutter Health v. Superior Court argued that the medical privacy statute imposed liability without fault after a computer holding more than 4 million patient records was stolen. That theory put potential nominal damages near $4 billion. The Court of Appeal in Sacramento rejected that reading in 2014 and held that loss of possession alone was not enough without proof that an unauthorized person viewed the records. The closest state law comes to liability without fault is the notification duty itself, which applies to every qualifying breach no matter how good the company’s security was.